Iris tells you when a story about a competitor reaches a stock you own. That only helps if the competitor links in our graph mean something. So we tested them against prices from 2019 to 2026, and we publish what held up, worded exactly as measured, with its caveat.
What we found
Competitors move the same way more often. Across 2019–2026, when a large S&P 500 stock made one of the day’s biggest moves, the competitors in our graph made a 2%+ move in the same direction about 1.8 times as often as the average S&P stock (95% CI 1.7–1.9x), ranging from 1.4x to 2.3x by year.
Same-day co-movement, not a forecast; stocks in the same industry co-move at a similar rate, and our competitor list is drawn from today’s graph.
It held before we curated the links. In 2022–2023, before our competitor edges were curated, named same-sector competitors of a big mover still moved 2%+ the same way about 2.1 times as often as a typical stock (95% CI 2.0–2.3x).
Uses today’s edges and today’s index membership; a different-period check, not a point-in-time one.
Rivals rarely move the opposite way. After a big earnings reaction (5%+), a company’s critical competitors made an opposite-direction 2%+ move only about one-third as often as a typical stock (0.32x, 95% CI 0.29–0.36x); rivals usually move with the news, not against it.
Critical rivals follow on earnings days. On a company’s big earnings-reaction day, its critical same-industry competitors moved in the same direction 73% of the time, versus 58% for other stocks in the same industry (2019–2026, about 4,200 observations).
These pairs move together on ordinary big-move days too, so this reflects structural co-movement rather than an earnings-specific signal.
Mapped rivals are more correlated than their industry. Within the same industry, companies we map as competitors have noticeably more correlated daily returns than unmapped same-industry pairs (+0.09 to +0.12 in market-adjusted correlation after controlling for size and liquidity).
The difference disappears among the least liquid stocks.
How we checked the data
Our price data was cross-checked against a second vendor: daily returns disagree by more than 2% on 0.035% of ticker-days, and our headline competitor co-movement result changes by 0.003x when recomputed on the second source.
Cross-check window April–October 2026.
What we do not claim
Some things we tested did not hold up, and some things would be easy to say but are not supported. So we do not say them:
- That the graph finds better peers than a correlation screen or an industry list. It does not; same-industry stocks co-move at a similar rate.
- That Iris predicts prices, next-day direction, or anything before the market moves. Everything above is same-day.
- That when one company stumbles its rivals gain. Usually they move with the news, not against it.
What it means for how Iris works
When a big story lands on a company you do not own but compete with one you do, Iris shows it, labels the link as a competitor, and tells you which way the competitors actually moved that day. It explains what moved and through which link. The fuller method is on our methodology page.